For most pituitary tumors, surgery remains the first-line treatment of symptomatic pituitary adenomas. Surgery is also chosen secondarily when medical treatment or radiotherapy fails; particularly for prolactin and growth hormone secreting adenomas. Surgery provides prompt relief from excess hormone secretion and mass effect. Surgery is also indicated in pituitary apoplexy with compressive symptoms regardless of the tumor type.
The transsphenoidal approach can be used for 95% of pituitary tumors. Exceptions are those tumors with significant temporal or anterior cranial fossa extension. In such circumstances, transcranial approaches are often necessary. Occasionally, combined transsphenoidal and transcranial approaches are used. Nevertheless, some surgeons extend the basic transsphenoidal exposure in order to remove some of these tumors and avoid a craniotomy (Fig. 3) (24,25,28,47).
The transsphenoidal approach is a versatile method for treating pituitary tumors (Table 4). Endoscopic approaches may be used in isolation or as an adjunct to the other transsphenoidal approaches (Fig. 1) (20-23). Computer-guided neuronavigational techniques are occasionally used in lieu of traditional fluoroscopic guidance (Fig. 2) (9,19). The role of neuronavigation is most pertinent in recurrent adenomas in which the midline anatomy has been distorted by previous transsphenoidal surgery. There are three basic variations of the transsphenoidal approach.
Table 4. Transsphenoidal Surgery for Adenomas: Personal Case Summary (1972-2000)
|
Type of Adenoma |
Number of Patients (%) N=3093 |
|---|---|
|
Functioning adenomas GH adenoma (Acromegaly) |
537 (17.4) |
|
PRL adenoma |
889 (28.7) |
|
ACTH adenoma (Cushing's disease) |
490 (15.8) |
|
Post-adrenalectomy ACTH adenoma (Nelson-Salassa syndrome) |
65 (2.1) |
|
TSH adenoma |
39 (1.3) |
|
Non-functioning adenomas |
1073 (34.7) |
Submucosal transseptal approach: The patient is placed in a lawn chair position and a hemi-transfixion incision is made just inside the nostril so that the scar cannot be seen after surgery (Fig. 4). Most often the entire surgery can be accomplished endonasally. Conversion to a sublabial approach is only necessary for large macroadenomas and children in whom the exposure through one nostril is often inadequate. A submucosal plane is developed along the nasal septum back to the level of the sphenoid sinus. Bone of the septum is harvested for use later in the operation. The bone in front of the pituitary gland is also removed and tumor is extracted in small fragments. Afterwards the saved bone is used to refashion the normal housing of the pituitary gland. Closure is rapid and consists of several interrupted absorbable sutures in the nasal mucosa and temporary nasal packing to promote healing of the mucosa.
Septal Pushover/Direct Sphenoidotomy: Increasing numbers of surgeries are being performed using incisions deeper within the nasal cavity. The incision for the septal pushover technique is made at the junction of the cartilaginous and bony septum. Submucosal tunnels are developed on either side of the bony septum until the sphenoid sinus is reached. Another option to reach the sphenoid sinus is by performing a direct sphenoidotomy. Using this method, no incision is made in the septum. Instead the posterior part of septum just in front of the sphenoid sinus is deflected laterally and the sphenoid sinus is entered directly. There are several advantages to these techniques. Because there is no submucosal dissection of the cartilaginous septum, the risk of an anterior nasal septal perforation is eliminated. In addition, there is less of a need for nasal packing postoperatively, a frequent cause of postoperative pain and discomfort. The main drawback of these more direct approaches is that the exposure is not as wide as can be achieved by the standard endonasal transseptal approach in which the cartilaginous septum can be more extensively mobilized.
Pure endoscopic approach: The pure endoscopic approach is also increasingly being performed at selected centers. Surgery begins at the anterior sphenoid wall where a direct anterior sphenoidotomy is performed. Some surgeons prefer to perform the surgery a using a single nostril. A binostril approach, however, provides more maneuverability. To achieve an adequate exposure for the binostril approach, the septum just in front of the sphenoid sinus is removed. This allows instruments to be used in both nostrils simultaneously. Although a specialized endoscope holder may be used during tumor removal, the “3-hand” technique is advocated by many surgeons. The “3-hand” technique requires two surgeons; one surgeon maneuvers the endoscope while another has both hands free to remove the tumor in the standard fashion. The endoscope provides a wider and more magnified field of view than the microscope. Because the local anatomy within the sphenoid sinus is so well visualized, intraoperative fluoroscopy most often does not need to be used. The option of using angled endoscopes allows surgeons to inspect for residual tumor particularly along the cavernous sinus walls and the suprasellar region. No nasal packing is required as the procedure is performed posterior to the septum. The main disadvantages the procedure’s learning curve and that the depth of field is less easily discernible to the unfamiliar surgeon.
Figure 1. Endoscopic approach. This technique may be used either primarily for the approach to and removal of adenomas or as an adjunct to the microscopic adenomectomy.
Figure 2. Frameless stereotaxy. Preoperative images may be stored and used for image guidance during operative procedures. Above, an intraoperative photograph showing the surgeon (ERL) using intraoperative image-guidance. Note that the usual C-arm fluoroscope is not necessary. Below, captured computer screen image as viewed by the surgeon.
Figure 3. Extended skull base approaches. Pituitary tumors with extension along the anterior skull base may be approached transsphenoidally by removing the planum sphenoidale.
Visual deficits in patients with non-functioning pituitary adenomas are improved in approximately 87%. Some visual deterioration may occur in 4%. Most patients with intact pituitary function preoperatively retain their normal function. Those with preoperative pituitary deficiency regain function in 27% of the cases. The remaining patients are managed with oral hormone replacement therapy. Tumor recurrence is also higher. Ten-year recurrence rates are approximately 16%, although only 6% require additional treatment (Table 5). On long-term follow-up, 83% of patients are alive and well without evidence of disease.
Table 5. Results of Transsphenoidal Surgery, 1972-2000 (N=3093)
|
Tumor |
Remission (%) |
Recurrence at 10 years (%) |
|---|---|---|
|
*Visual improvement occurs in 87% of those with preoperative visual loss. |
||
|
Non-functioning adenoma |
Not applicable* |
16 |
|
GH adenoma Microadenoma |
88 |
1.3 |
|
Macroadenoma |
65 |
|
|
PRL adenoma Microadenoma |
87 |
13 |
|
Macroadenoma |
56 |
|
|
ACTH adenoma Microadenoma |
91 |
12 (Adults), 42 (Pediatric) |
|
Macroadenoma |
65 |
|
Using strict criteria for remission, transsphenoidal surgery obtains remission in 88% of patients with acromegaly with microadenomas and 65% of those harboring macroadenomas (Table 5). Acromegalic symptoms are improved in 95% and recurrence is less than 2 percent at ten years. Ninety seven percent of patients have preserved normal pituitary function. Seventy-two percent of patients with greater than ten year follow-up, including those with adjunctive therapy, are alive and well without evidence of active disease.
Patients with prolactinomas who present for surgery are most often those who have failed medical management. Prolactin levels are normalized in 87% of microadenomas and 56% of macroadenomas (Table 5). The recurrence rate among those patients who are normalized after a transsphenoidal operation is 13% at ten years. Preserved pituitary function occurs in all but 3%.
Surgical management of Cushing's disease achieves a 91% remission rate for microadenomas, but falls to 65% for those with macroadenomas (Table 5). While twelve percent of adults experience recurrence after ten years, a much higher percentage of children may develop recurrent Cushing's disease. Postoperative stereotactic radiosurgery has achieved remission in approximately 68% of patients whose disease either did not remit following surgery or recurred.
The overall mortality rate for transsphenoidal surgery is less than 0.5% (Table 6). Major morbidity (cerebrospinal fluid leak, meningitis, stroke, intracranial hemorrhage, and visual loss) occurs in between 1 and 2% of cases. Less serious complications (sinus disease, nasal septal perforations, and wound issues) occur in approximately 6.5%. Larger invasive tumors and giant adenomas are associated with a higher morbidity.
Table 6. Complications of Transsphenoidal Surgery (1972-2000)
|
Outcome Measure |
Incidence (%) |
|---|---|
|
Mortality |
<0.5 |
|
Major complication (CSF leak, meningitis, ischemic stroke, intracranial hemorrhage, vascular injury, visual loss) |
1.5 |
|
Minor complication (sinus disease, septal perforations, epistaxis, wound infections and hematomas) |
6.5 |